Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Single Family for Sale: 5031 Sutherland Avenue, St Louis, MO 63109

5 beds
2 full baths
2,686 sqft
$375,000
$375,000
5031 Sutherland Avenue, St Louis, MO 63109
5 beds
2 full baths
2,686 sqft
$375,000
Remove from
Favorites
Add to
Favorites
Add to
Trip Map
Hide Share or
Email
Price:
$375,000

Type Single Family
Style 2 Story
Beds 5
Baths 2 full baths
Total Living Area 2,686 sqft
Square Footage 2,686 sqft
Lot Size 0.11 acres
Year Built 1923
Taxes Paid $5,520

City St Louis
County St Louis City
School District St. Louis City
Subdivision Christys Add

MLS 26004964
Status Active Under Contract
DOM 14 days
Welcome to this stunning century home located in the highly sought-after Southampton neighborhood. Originally a two-family, the thoughtful conversion to a single-family residence created an open, modern floor plan while preserving the home's timeless charm. Architectural highlights include original fireplace mantels with built-in bookshelves, stained glass windows and hardwood floors throughout. From the moment you step inside, you'll be drawn to the inviting, light-filled, and generously sized rooms. The main level offers a comfortable living room, formal dining room, two bedrooms, and a show-stopping kitchen featuring Quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, open shelving, and abundant storage. A lovely full bath completes the first floor. Upstairs, a flexible layout allows you to tailor the space to your needs. The current owners created a gorgeous owner's suite with an attached sitting area. There are three additional bedrooms and two bonus rooms--perfect for a home office, nursery, or creative space. A tastefully renovated bath completes the 2nd floor. Additional features include zoned HVAC (2 years old) and tankless hot water heater (1 year old). Out back is a large level fenced yard with a concrete pad--great spot for a patio or potential parking. Ideally located near restaurants, shopping, and many of St. Louis's finest attractions, this home is truly move-in ready. Come see it for yourself and fall in love!

Room Features

Basement Description Unfinished, Full

Lot & Building Features

Appliances Tankless Water Heater, Free-Standing Gas Oven, Water Softener, Range Hood, Disposal, Refrigerator, Microwave, Dishwasher
Architecture Historic
Construction Brick
Cooling Central Air
Heating Natural Gas, Forced Air
Interior Decor Historic Millwork, Chandelier, Bookcases, High Ceilings, Breakfast Room, Custom Cabinetry, Separate Dining, Eat-in Kitchen, Open Floorplan
Parking Description No Garage, On Street
Sewer Public Sewer
Tax Year 2025
Taxes Paid $5,520
Water Public
Fireplaces 2

Community and Schools

Elementary School Buder Elem.
Junior High School Long Middle Community Ed. Center
Senior High School Roosevelt High

Price History of 5031 Sutherland Avenue, St Louis, MO

Date Name Price Difference
01/28/2026 Listing Price $375,000 N/A
*Information provided by REWS for your reference only. The accuracy of this information cannot be verified and is not guaranteed.

Comparable Properties Sold Near By

Low
$267,000
$105 / sqft
Average
$384,560
$147 / sqft
High
$480,000
$174 / sqft

Address City Zip Beds Baths Price Sq. Ft. $/SQFT Sold Date
This Listing St Louis 63109 5 2.0 $375,000 2,686 $140 N/A
4031 Parker Avenue St Louis 63116 5 3.0 $360,000 2,608 $138 02/11/2025
3837 Wyoming Street St Louis 63116 4 3.0 $480,000 2,766 $174 03/31/2025
7115 Field Avenue St Louis 63116 5 3.0 $425,000 2,752 $154 03/04/2025
3641 Utah Place St Louis 63116 5 2.0 $395,000 2,508 $157 04/24/2025
5020 Creighton Drive St Louis 63123 6 3.0 $467,500 2,588 $181 05/07/2025
5410 Finkman Street St Louis 63109 4 3.0 $475,000 2,492 $191 05/29/2025
8741 Fatima Drive Unincorporated 63123 4 3.0 $360,000 2,523 $143 07/01/2025
2915 Meramec Street St Louis 63118 4 2.0 $267,000 2,538 $105 07/17/2025
3817 Castleman Avenue St Louis 63110 5 2.0 $360,000 2,770 $130 08/11/2025
3878 Connecticut Street St Louis 63116 4 2.0 $329,000 2,578 $128 08/05/2025
6454 Virginia Avenue St Louis 63111 4 3.0 $305,000 2,600 $117 08/27/2025
743 Dover Place St Louis 63111 5 2.0 $299,900 2,652 $113 09/26/2025
3521 Arsenal Street St Louis 63118 4 3.0 $435,000 2,616 $166 08/22/2025
4216 Shenandoah Avenue St Louis 63110 4 3.0 $420,000 2,606 $161 09/19/2025
3942 JUNIATA Street St Louis 63116 4 2.0 $390,000 2,566 $152 12/19/2025

Map of 5031 Sutherland Avenue, St Louis, MO

Location Map Street View
Photo of Christy Andrews
Christy Andrews
Real Estate Agent
Direct: 314-280-3017
Office
3537 S Kingshighway Blvd
Saint Louis, MO 63139
314-353-0336
Listed by Garcia Properties, Christy Andrews
$
20%
1.472%
6.75%
$
$
$
Monthly Payment
Principal & Interest
Monthly Taxes
Monthly HOA
Monthly Home Ins.
Monthly PMI

5031 Sutherland Avenue (MLS #26004964) is a 2 story single family home located in St Louis, MO. This single family home is 2,686 sqft and on a lot of 5,001 sqft (or 0.11 acres) with 5 bedrooms and 2 baths. This property was listed on 01/28/2026 and has been priced for sale at $375,000.

The 4 bedroom single family home at 5410 Finkman Street in St Louis is nearby and sold for $475,000 on 05/29/2025. Another nearby 5 bedroom single family home, 4031 Parker Avenue in St Louis sold for $360,000 on 02/11/2025.

Nearby zip codes are 63110, 63111, 63116, 63123 and 63139. This property neighbors other cities such as Affton, Maplewood, Shrewsbury and Wentzville.

Maris

Listing Last updated . Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available. Walk Score map and data provided by Walk Score. Google map provided by Google. Bing map provided by Microsoft Corporation.

All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Listing information courtesy of: Garcia Properties

Listings displaying the MARIS logo are courtesy of the participants of Mid America Regional Information Systems Internet Data Exchange